
by Dani Straughan 8 min read
Coffee workers have organized around wages, scheduling, safety, and their ability to have a say at work. The cafe organizing campaigns described here grew during the COVID-19 pandemic, when face-to-face service made workplace risks especially visible.
A labor union gives workers a way to bargain together over those conditions.
A union represents workers in bargaining with an employer over pay, hours, and other terms of employment. Workers organize together to decide what to seek and how to pursue it (National Labor Relations Board, "Your Right to Form a Union").
In the original interview, Aiden Graham of the NC AFL-CIO described two major milestones: winning representation and negotiating a first contract. His wording below combines them, but the legal distinction matters:
"For a union to be officially recognized, they have to pass two tests. One is demonstrating the majority of the workers wanting a union, either through signing cards and voluntary recognition by the employer or an election, and then successfully negotiating a first contract."
A union can become the recognized bargaining representative through voluntary recognition or an NLRB election and certification. It can hold that status before securing a first contract. There isn't a general rule requiring a contract within one year of the first organizing meeting (NLRB, "Your Right to Form a Union"; "Frequently Asked Questions").
Key takeaway: A union is an organized group of workers who bargain collectively with employers for better wages, benefits, and working conditions. Collective demands carry more weight than individual ones.
Union organizing and labor campaigns helped establish many workplace protections. Today, collective bargaining gives represented workers a formal way to negotiate the terms of their jobs.
Unions can negotiate wages, benefits, scheduling, and workplace procedures. Workers also have rights to concerted action under federal labor law. Strike protections depend on the purpose, timing, and conduct of the action (NLRB, "The Right to Strike").
The pandemic highlighted how much risk service industry workers face. Coffee shops are high-volume, and most customer interactions happen face to face. It's a health risk to work during a public health crisis. Unions can be a powerful tool for organizing around workers' rights.
Bargaining allows workers to choose representatives and make proposals together. The terms they secure depend on the negotiations and the agreement reached.
Cafe workers have faced workplace issues for a long time, though unionization has historically been low in the sector. According to the US Bureau of Labor Statistics, the food and beverage service industry has one of the lowest unionization rates in the country (Bureau of Labor Statistics).
Union membership in U.S. food services and drinking places, 2025. BLS estimates use 11 months of data because October was unavailable.
As workplace issues became more visible during the COVID-19 pandemic, workers started seeing what unionization could deliver.
In 2021, Colectivo workers voted to organize with the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers. The organizing drive covered roughly 400 workers and became a prominent example of cafe workers pursuing collective bargaining (Waxman).
Before Colectivo, Buffalo, N.Y.-based SPoT Coffee had been the largest group of organized coffee service workers. Starting with 12 members, the SPoT union grew to 130 members across New York locations ("SPoT Coffee Workers").
As a unified body, unions ensure that workers' voices aren't lost. Beyond advocating for higher wages, labor unions affect employee benefits, workplace health and safety, and many other work-related issues.
In 2025, union members had median weekly earnings of $1,404, compared with $1,174 for nonunion workers. These national figures cover many industries and occupations; they don't measure what joining a union would add to a particular barista's pay. BLS notes that the comparison doesn't control for differences between the groups (Bureau of Labor Statistics).
A union contract may include just-cause rules for discipline and dismissal, along with a grievance process. The protection depends on the contract. Union membership alone doesn't guarantee a job or require an employer to prove a dismissal case before taking action ("All About Unions").
Securing those terms requires a contract, and first-contract bargaining can be difficult.
One obstacle unions face is employers who create roadblocks to contract negotiation. Employers are required by law to negotiate in good faith with unions representing employees ("Bargaining in Good Faith"). It can be hard to hold companies accountable when it comes to good-faith negotiations, though.
Graham explains that many unions who win their first election aren't able to negotiate a first contract. Holding off on negotiations is one of the "..tactics by employers to try to avoid bargaining. Right now, there's no requirement that the employer has to settle a first contract."
The interview also discussed proposed changes to labor law.
Graham discussed first-contract arbitration as one proposal in the Protecting the Right to Organize Act, known as the PRO Act. At the time, he said "the ProAct could change and could say. . . if the company is not bargaining in good faith. . . arbitration could be a last measure that the union could use to get that first contract." This is historical discussion of proposed legislation. It doesn't establish a current right to first-contract arbitration; current bargaining obligations are described by the NLRB.
So-called "right-to-work" laws have a long history in the United States, going back to the Taft-Hartley Act of 1947 ("Right-to-Work Law").
Federal labor law allows states to prohibit union-security agreements that make certain payments to a union a condition of employment. These state laws are commonly called right-to-work laws (NLRB, "Union Dues").
Right-to-work laws concern union-security payments. Workers covered by federal labor law can still organize and choose a union, and strike rights are governed separately. Required financial support and union membership aren't interchangeable concepts (NLRB, "Union Dues").
North Carolina's right-to-work law doesn't prevent covered private-sector workers from choosing a union. In the original interview, Graham connected organizing with freedom of assembly: "right to form a union is basically a constitutionally protected right. Freedom to assemble is laid out in the Constitution."
There's often confusion, especially in North Carolina. Graham continues: "part of the confusion, especially when it comes to North Carolina, is a separate law, General Statute 95-98. It was passed around the same time as right-to-work laws, and there are only two or three states in the US that still have this law on the books."
North Carolina General Statute 95-98 prohibits collective-bargaining contracts between public employers and labor organizations concerning public employees. This is a separate restriction from right-to-work law. It doesn't describe private-sector cafe bargaining (North Carolina General Assembly).
Key takeaway: Covered private-sector cafe workers in North Carolina can organize under federal labor law. Right-to-work rules concern union-security payments; the state's public-sector bargaining restriction is a separate law.
Union busting is an umbrella term for activities meant to prevent or disrupt union formation in the workplace. It remains one of the biggest obstacles to organizing.
Starbucks workers in Buffalo began organizing with Workers United in 2021, drawing national attention to cafe organizing. The campaign showed cafe workers pursuing a formal role in decisions about pay and working conditions (Slater).
In Southern California, the union representing former Augie's workers reported in December 2020 that the NLRB had issued a complaint alleging retaliation after cafe closures and layoffs. A complaint sets out allegations to be addressed through the agency's process; it isn't a final adjudication that the employer violated the law (United Electrical, Radio and Machine Workers of America).
Employers can violate federal labor law by threatening workers, retaliating against protected organizing, or unlawfully surveilling union activity. The NLRB investigates charges and distinguishes allegations from findings (NLRB, "Employer/Union Rights and Obligations").
Workers' unions and farmer cooperatives both involve collective organization, but they represent different relationships and shouldn't be treated as the same institution.
The Oromia Coffee Farmers Cooperative Union is a union of coffee farmer cooperatives in Ethiopia. It organizes producer services and market access, which differs from an employee union bargaining with a cafe employer.
Oromia was founded in 1999. Its role in connecting member cooperatives with export markets provides another example of people working together within coffee's supply chain (Oromia Coffee Farmers Cooperative Union).
Oromia describes its work as grading, marketing, and exporting coffee for member cooperatives. That collective access to buyers is a producer service, separate from an employee union's negotiation of wages and working conditions (Oromia Coffee Farmers Cooperative Union).
For buyers, the useful questions are who belongs to the organization, how decisions are made, and which services or payments members receive.
There are a range of ways coffee consumers can support unions within the industry. Graham suggests that "first and foremost is to follow the lead of the workers." He describes how "union work is inherently risky. . . people are putting a lot at risk, and it's important that things stay quiet, and sometimes for quite a while until workers are organized enough to withstand any pushback from employers."
The rules are often rigged in favor of corporations and business owners. Graham continues: "A lot of times, managers will just fire people. Even though, legally, they aren't allowed to do that, they'll do a cost/benefit analysis, and are sometimes just willing to risk it."
He doesn't want people to feel discouraged from organizing, and he's hopeful about the future of the labor movement. There are a lot of resources available.
For those new to organizing, Graham suggests Labor Notes as a strong beginner resource. They offer materials about organizing backed by around 40 years of movement experience.
As more workers in the coffee industry refuse to settle for poor treatment, change can follow. But it takes organization. Graham suggests that "we need pretty substantial labor law reform (in the US) to start going in the right direction." That process is slow.
He offers one other suggestion:
"The other thing that we need is workers organizing, anywhere and everywhere they can."
Let's get to work.
Special thanks to Aiden Graham of NC AFL-CIO.
"All About Unions." Workplace Fairness, 2021, www.workplacefairness.org/labor-unions#2.
Arellano, Gustavo. "Did Baristas Lose Jobs over COVID-19 or Unionization?" Los Angeles Times, 19 July 2020, www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-07-19/baristas-lose-jobs-covid-19-unionization-augies-coffee-house.
"Bargaining in Good Faith with Employees' Union Representative (Section 8(d) & 8(a)(5))." National Labor Relations Board, www.nlrb.gov/about-nlrb/rights-we-protect/the-law/bargaining-in-good-faith-with-employees-union-representative.
News Release: Union Members, 2025. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 18 Feb. 2026, www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/union2.pdf.
"Right-to-Work Law." Encyclopaedia Britannica, 2021, www.britannica.com/topic/right-to-work-law.
Slater, Joseph. "Starbucks Baristas Are on the Verge of Forming a Union. The Company Is Pushing Back." The Washington Post, 23 Nov. 2021, www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2021/11/23/starbucks-union-buffalo/.
"SPoT Coffee Workers Make Union History." Barista Magazine, 2020, www.baristamagazine.com/spot-coffee-workers-make-union-history/.
"Starbucks Faces Expansion of Labor Union Drive Beyond New York." CNBC, 18 Nov. 2021, www.cnbc.com/2021/11/18/starbucks-faces-expansion-of-labor-union-drive-beyond-new-york-.html.
Waxman, Nick. "Colectivo Coffee Workers Form America's Largest Cafe Union." Eater Chicago, 24 Aug. 2021, chicago.eater.com/2021/8/24/22639308/colectivo-coffee-union-victory-largest-coffee-chain-nlrb-ruling.
"Why the US ProAct Matters for the Right to Unionize: Questions and Answers." Human Rights Watch, 29 Apr. 2021, www.hrw.org/news/2021/04/29/why-us-pro-act-matters-right-unionize-questions-and-answers.
National Labor Relations Board. “Your Right to Form a Union.” Accessed 29 Oct. 2026. Read source.
National Labor Relations Board. “Frequently Asked Questions.” Accessed 29 Oct. 2026. Read source.
National Labor Relations Board. “Union Dues.” Accessed 29 Oct. 2026. Read source.
National Labor Relations Board. “NLRA and the Right to Strike.” Accessed 29 Oct. 2026. Read source.
National Labor Relations Board. “Employer/Union Rights and Obligations.” Accessed 29 Oct. 2026. Read source.
North Carolina General Assembly. “G.S. 95-98.” Accessed 29 Oct. 2026. Read source.
United States Bureau of Labor Statistics. “Union Members, 2025.” 18 Feb. 2026. Eleven-month averages omit October; comparability and state-level cautions apply. Read source.
United Electrical, Radio and Machine Workers of America. “National Labor Relations Board Sides with Fired Augie’s Workers.” 16 Dec. 2020. A party statement describing a complaint, not a final merits decision. Read source.
Oromia Coffee Farmers Cooperative Union. “The Union.” Accessed 29 Oct. 2026. Read source.
Yes. Covered private-sector coffee shop workers can organize under federal labor law in right-to-work states, including North Carolina. Right-to-work rules concern union-security payments; North Carolina's separate public-sector bargaining restriction doesn't govern private-sector cafe contracts.
Starbucks workers in Buffalo began organizing with Workers United in 2021, drawing national attention to cafe unionization. Their campaign made questions about pay, working conditions, and collective bargaining visible to a broad coffee audience. Organizing, winning representation, and securing a contract are separate milestones.
BLS reports median weekly earnings of $1,404 for union members and $1,174 for nonunion workers in 2025 across industries. Those figures aren't specific to baristas and don't control for differences in occupation, industry, and other factors. They don't predict the pay change for a particular coffee worker.
Union busting describes efforts to prevent or disrupt organizing. Threats, unlawful surveillance, and retaliation against protected activity can violate federal labor law. In the Augie's case discussed here, the workers' union reported a December 2020 NLRB complaint; a complaint states allegations and isn't a final adjudication.
The Protecting the Right to Organize Act is a legislative proposal discussed in the article's historical interview, including proposals concerning first-contract bargaining. That discussion doesn't establish a current right to arbitration or an enacted protection. For current bargaining rights and obligations, consult the NLRB's guidance.